Fans of the Great British Bake Off are divided over the new signature challenge involving the bakers’ family members.
For the new Audience Choice Week, the bakers had to create a baked cheesecake with a member of their family.
While the signature challenge came directly from the audience, a few fans are still not sure on the choice.
Oh this is gonna be a messy bake isn’t it 😂 I would NOT want any member of my family attempting to “help” me #GBBO
— Paul (@InTheSavgeGardn) October 6, 2026
Fans are divided about the family signature challenge
At the start of the challenge, Noel Fielding said: “This is going to be carnage.”
With each baker bringing in a member of their family, the number of people in the Bake Off tent has now doubled.
Many fans have taken to social media to share their thoughts on the new signature challenge.
One person said: “Ugh this is so gimmicky, I hate it.
“Bring back the old Bake Off with classic bakes.”
Another person said: “oh here we go. Unnecessary people in the tent. Why? WHY?”
A third person said: “Baking with a relative seems like a cheat code, no?”
Some people quite like the new challenge with one person saying: “I'm loving the family members in the tent already.”
Another person said: “Ok this pairing up thing is immediately a huge win.”
Other people agreed that the challenge could be messy.
One person added: “Oh this is gonna be a messy bake isn’t it.
“I would NOT want any member of my family attempting to ‘help’ me.”
Who is judging and hosting the Great British Bake Off?
Paul Hollywood is returning as one of the judges on the show after he first joined in 2010 alongside Mary Berry.
Paul then worked with Prue Leith after the show moved from BBC One to Channel 4.
Recommended reading
All the themed weeks for The Great British Bake Off - including a brand new addition
Bake Off viewers call for baker to be 'removed' from show after cheeky comment
Bake Off fans divided by Nigella Lawson’s strange habit when judging bakes
After it was announced earlier this year that Prue would be leaving the show, Nigella Lawson has been brought in as the second judge.
Other familiar faces include the hosts, Alison Hammond and Noel Fielding, who are also returning to bring more chaos to the show.
Did you like the family signature challenge or prefer classic Bake Off challenges? Let us know in the comments.
Share